Composite vs. Wood Fencing in 2025—The Smart Guide for Florida Yards

By Smithery Post and Plank 08/09/25

Thinking fence material—wood or composite? It’s more than a style decision. It’s about value, durability, upkeep, and what suits your space best in the Sebastian, FL climate.

Here’s your clear, research-informed breakdown for making the best call—informed, local, and future-ready.

Composite Fencing: Built for Longevity

Longevity & Resilience: Composite fences—made from recycled wood fibers and plastics—last up to 30–50 years, beating wood’s 15–20-year range. Reddit
Low-Maintenance: No staining or sealing needed—just an occasional wash with soap and water. virtuefence
Weather & Pest Resistance: They stand strong against heat, rain, humidity, and insects—no warping, cracking, or splintering. The Spruce
Eco-Conscious Choice: Made with recycled materials and minimal replacements needed, it’s a smart choice for the eco-aware homeowner. virtuefenceWiki
Design & Fade Options: Available in wood-like textures, modern greys, or earth tones; many options are fade-resistant. First Star Exteriors
The Trade-Off: Composite comes at a higher upfront cost, typically $30–70 per linear foot, compared to wood's $15–45 / ft—though long-term savings can be substantial. Shoe Makes New

If you’re in or around Sebastian, Florida, choosing between composite and wood fencing in 2025 isn’t just about curb appeal—it’s a long-term decision that affects durability, cost, and maintenance. Make it wisely.

Wood Fencing: Classic Charm with Considerations

Aesthetic Appeal: Wood offers timeless beauty—rich tones, grain variation, customizable designs for a personalized look. Reddit
Lower Upfront Cost: Generally cheaper to install initially—making it accessible for tight budgets. First Star Exteriors
High Maintenance: To stay beautiful and functional, expect to stain or seal every 2–3 years, and watch for warping or rot. Reddit
Durability Trade-offs: With proper upkeep, wood fences can reach 20+ years, especially with rot-resistant species like cedar—but they still won’t outlast composite. 12skyfenceco

Composite Vertical Plank Fence with Gate

Solid composite fence in a warm tan color featuring vertical planks, decorative crown post caps, and a matching gate with black metal hinges and latch, bordered by small green shrubs.

Vertical Plank Crowned Post Wooden Ceder Fence

Freshly installed cedar privacy fence with vertical planks and evenly spaced decorative crown post caps, set in a landscaped suburban yard with green grass and trees.

Vertical Plank Composite Fence with Crowned Posts

Close-up view of a composite privacy fence with vertical planks in a muted beige tone, topped with white decorative crown-style post caps, set against a backdrop of blurred greenery.

What’s Trending in 2025

Composite Popularity Rising: Homeowners across Florida are turning to composite for its low-maintenance and lasting performance, especially in humid climates. FenceTractencom
Capping Technology: Composite with full capping protects against moisture and staining—boosting longevity and preserving the look. Ultra Decking

Choose What You Like for Your Brevard County Nieghborhood!

Factor	Composite	Wood
Budget	Higher upfront cost	Lower initial cost
Maintenance	Easy upkeep (wash only)	Regular staining/sealing required
Longevity	30–50 years	15–20 years with care
Weather & Pest Resistance	Extremely durable	Requires ongoing weatherproofing
Design Flexibility	Limited to manufacturer styles	Full customization ability
Eco Impact	Made with recycled content	Natural material, but treatment needed

Final Word

If durability, low upkeep, and eco-conscious design top your list? Composite is the 2025 smart choice. But if authentic wood, flexibility, and a tight budget matter more—you can still win with high-quality cedar or treated wood—just plan for the maintenance.

Here at Smithery Post and Plank, we can walk you through the cost comparisons, styling options, and local suitability for Sebastian, FL. Let’s find the best fence that fits your home, not just your budget.

📍 Serving Sebastian, Micco, Fellsmere, Wabasso & beyond.
📲 Ready to fence smart? Contact us for a consultation.

About SMITHERY

We sustain our company on reliability, great communication, integrity and attention to detail. We are American owned and operated, and strongly believe in giving our absolute best on all of our projects. With over 25 years experience, we are experts in our trade, and will always keep you educated on your particular task or project. Large to small, we do it all! Call today!

ABOUT US

What We Do

SMITHERY provides: Chain link, Aluminum, Wood, Vinyl and PVC fence install and repair services. We also specialize in deck, porch, gazebo, and free-standing porch build and repair.

Service Areas

We provide service to the following cities in Florida: Melbourne, Vero Beach, Palm Bay, Cocoa, Titusville, Merritt Island, Sebastian, Orlando, Rockledge, Cocoa Beach, Fellsmere, Roseland, Winter Beach, Melbourne Beach, Satellite Beach, Scottsmoor, Mims, Sharpes, Patrick AFB, Indialantic, Wabasso, Cape Canaveral, Malabar

FEATURED

Contact SMITHERY

772-918-8468
9512 Honeysuckle Dr
Sebastian Fl 32976

Please Contact us for business hours.

Some media on this site may be simulated for illustration purposes

Brevard County 17-FE CT 00150. Indian River County #22931 # City of Sebastian #2283.